Common Core for an
Uncommon People?
Despite Diane Ravitch’s recent expose in Reign of Error that American students
are doing quite well in accurately measured international skill tests (National
Assessment of Educational Progress - NAEP), it would seem that the politically
vogue topic of Common Core is still front and center stage for Secretary of
Education Arne Duncan. Beyond his recent
gaffe that white suburban “soccer moms’” concerns about educational emphases be
dismissed, he has ordered full speed ahead for all those that would promote the
“failure” of public education. Those are
good friends, like Bruce Rauner or Rahm Emanuel.
Often we retired educators carefully argue from our past
experiences, our great bank of past experiences and knowledge, or our
appreciation for the individual’s educational experience within a context of
meaningful moments. It might be poverty,
for example, Arne… Arne is not about to
listen…or think about that.
Please find below an intelligent and lucid look at what Common
Core does not have to do with teaching from an active and brilliant youngster
in the classroom now. Stay with her
blog as cited at end of her comments.
Poverty is the real reason why students
(and schools) don’t do well
Try this out- skip dinner, then
breakfast the following day. Then try to learn a new skill, or take a test. It
isn’t easy, even for adults. Yet that’s what a growing number of kids in
America face daily. Add to that the fact that some stayed up until 2 am
with a sick sibling, or listening to fighting. Add to that the kids who have no
one at home to help with homework, or read to them. The kids that experience
violence at home, drug use, homelessness. This is not a small percentage. In 17
states, students below the poverty line are the majority of public school
students. Take a second to let that sink in. More kids are poor than aren’t in
many places. That’s insane.
Unemployment is rampant, minimum wage
barely feeds and houses an individual let alone a family, food and heating oil
prices are rising. I don’t blame parents, in most cases. For every individual
who is addicted to drugs and hitting their kids, there are many more who are
trying as hard as they can, working multiple jobs just to feed and clothe their
kids. How do we expect them to find time to read books to their kids when they
work 18+ hours a day? Furthermore, how do we expect teachers to stay in
districts where poverty is rampant when test scores are tied to pay?
In a recent article by Elaine Weiss, she
asks “What if we have actually been teaching the right skills in US schools all
along – math and reading, science and civics, along with creativity,
perseverance and team-building? What if these were as important a hundred years
ago for nurturing innovative farmers and developers of new automobiles as they
are now for creating the next generation of tech innovators? What if these are
the very characteristics of US schools that have made us such a strong public
education nation, and the current shift toward a narrower agenda just dilutes
that strength? What if, rather than raising standards, and testing students
more, the biggest change we need to address is that of our student body?”
We are pouring money into systems to
assess our nations teachers and students. Those of us within education (and
arguably those with any common sense) know why there are deficits. Imagine if
we spent that money on universal pre-K, reduced cost breakfast, counselors,
special educators? We wouldn’t need a test to let us know which schools were performing
poorly if we spent our resources fighting against poverty.
I know that many will read this and
write me off. As lazy, bitter, union-driven, out of touch. I will point out
these facts- I am inherently optimistic because I hold the future in my hands
every day. I question every decision my union makes by asking if it is in the
best interest of my kids. It would be so much easier to give in and go into
lock step with these standards and initiatives. It’s much easier to use a
curriculum someone else wrote (and profited off of) than write one yourself.
Standardized tests take no time out of my personal life to make. They are
easier than performance assessments, rubrics, student designed projects. This
is the harder route. The route of being ostracized, condemned, criticized.
Here’s the thing, though. I don’t give a
damn. I don’t care what anyone other than my students and their parents think.
I know these practices are bad for kids. I know they won’t help my students
become real learners, or the successful adults I know they will be. So I will
fight them, yell about them, push back against them. My kids are the ones who
really matter. I’m doing this for them.
Read more of this wonderful and
promising educator at the following:
I was one of those children who went without multiple meals as a child. I also spent most of my childhood, non-school waking hours caring for my profoundly "mentally retarded" younger brother who was unexpectedly born breech. His convulsions were incredibly violent. My alcoholic father and a childhood of non-specific sleeping-waking patterns while still attending school yet missing many days of classes created their own sets of problems. We moved often because of being evicted for non-payment of rent. Yes, our furniture was put out on the streets.
ReplyDeleteI was fortunate; for some reason I survived. Other people had worse situations and their lives did not take the same twists and turns that fortunately led to my education and choice to teach for over 30 years.
I strongly agree with everything that tattooteacher said, even though I personally have no tattoos and have no intentions of ever having any. Tattoos are superficial, what tattoteacher says is not. She has insights that need to be shared.
- Ken Previti